Shelter Island Heights is a city of approximately 1,000 people in New York, United States. Located in the Eastern Time Zone at 41.1°N latitude.
In 2025, Shelter Island Heights recorded an average annual temperature of 53°F — about 2.7°F above the 30-year normal of 50°F. The hottest day reached 86°F in July; the coldest was 18°F in January. Total precipitation was 38 inches (drier than usual). The wettest month was May.
View current conditions and forecast for Shelter Island Heights · More cities in New York